AS/400 (IBM i) Modernization: Migration Options, Costs & Key Considerations

AS/400 (IBM i) has long supported mission-critical business systems in manufacturing, wholesale distribution, and logistics. These systems often manage essential operations such as order processing, inventory management, production planning, and accounting.

However, as applications remain in operation for many years, organizations may face challenges related to maintaining RPG and COBOL programs, securing experienced engineers, and integrating with modern applications.

One approach to addressing these challenges is AS/400 modernization.

Modernization does not necessarily mean replacing IBM i with another platform. Organizations can also improve applications, user interfaces, and data integration while retaining their existing IBM i environment.

This article explains the main AS/400 modernization approaches, migration options, cost factors, potential risks, and practical steps for planning a modernization project.

01. What Is AS/400 (IBM i), and Why Consider Modernization?

AS/400 was introduced by IBM in 1988 as a business computing system. Over time, its product architecture and technology evolved into the IBM i platform, which runs on IBM Power systems.

IBM i continues to receive updates and enhancements. Therefore, using AS/400 or IBM i does not automatically mean an organization needs to replace its entire system.

Nevertheless, changing business requirements may create several challenges:

  • Difficulty understanding and maintaining RPG or COBOL application logic
  • Dependence on a limited number of experienced engineers
  • Growing requirements for integration with web applications and external services
  • Longer development cycles for new features and business process changes
  • Increasing demand for cloud integration and enterprise data analytics

When planning AS/400 modernization, it is important to distinguish platform-related issues from challenges caused by application complexity and long-established operational practices.

In many cases, selectively modernizing applications while preserving reliable existing capabilities can be a practical option.

02. Four Main AS/400 Modernization Approaches

Organizations can modernize AS/400 systems through several approaches, including retaining IBM i, gradually replacing applications, migrating the hosting environment, or rebuilding the system.

The appropriate approach depends on the current architecture, business requirements, available budget, and operational capabilities.

ApproachOverviewKey Considerations
Retain IBM iMaintain existing applications while improving interfaces, APIs, and integrations.Existing asset utilization, maintainability, system integration
Incremental Application ModernizationGradually replace selected business functions with modern technologies.Legacy and new system coexistence, data synchronization, business impact
Hosting Environment MigrationMove workloads to compatible hosting environments or cloud services that support IBM i.Compatibility, licensing, infrastructure and operational requirements
System RebuildingRebuild business applications using technologies such as Java or replace them with modern software packages.Requirements definition, data migration, development and testing effort

For example, moving an IBM i environment to a compatible cloud platform is different from migrating RPG applications to Java.

Before selecting an approach, organizations should clearly define which applications, databases, infrastructure components, and operational processes are included in the modernization scope.

03. AS/400 Migration Options: Retaining IBM i, Cloud Migration, or Rebuilding

When evaluating AS/400 migration options, organizations should consider business compatibility and long-term operational requirements rather than selecting new technology solely for its technical advantages.

For example, retaining IBM i may be appropriate when preserving existing business logic is a priority. In contrast, rebuilding applications or adopting enterprise software may be considered when business processes also need significant changes.

ComparisonRetain IBM iCloud MigrationSystem Rebuilding
Existing AssetsCan generally be retainedDepends on target compatibilityMay require redesign
Application ChangesTargeted improvementsDepends on migration methodOften extensive
Business ImpactChanges can be limitedInfrastructure and operations require assessmentBroader business testing is often required
Primary ObjectiveImprove maintainability and integrationOptimize infrastructure and operationsModernize applications and business processes

Cloud migration can involve moving an existing IBM i workload to a compatible cloud environment. Rebuilding applications on a different technology stack is a separate undertaking.

Understanding this distinction helps organizations compare the required effort, business impact, and expected outcomes more accurately.

04. Five Key Factors Affecting AS/400 Migration Costs

AS/400 migration costs vary depending on system size, business logic complexity, data migration requirements, and the selected modernization approach.

Without assessing the current environment, it is difficult to provide a reliable estimate for an entire modernization project.

The following five factors commonly influence project costs.

Cost FactorWhat to Assess
Current System SizeNumber of programs, screens, batch processes, and data volume
Business Logic ComplexityRPG and COBOL processing rules, custom business logic, and documentation quality
Data Migration ComplexityData structures, transformation rules, historical records, and data quality
External IntegrationsERP, EDI, APIs, file-based interfaces, and connected applications
Testing and Production CutoverLegacy-to-new comparison testing, performance validation, cutover rehearsals, and operational transition

For example, improving interfaces and integrations while retaining IBM i requires a different level of effort from rebuilding an entire business system using Java or another technology.

To estimate costs effectively, organizations should first assess existing application assets and dependencies, then define the migration scope and target approach.

Cost Planning Tip: Compare modernization options using total cost of ownership (TCO), including initial development, licensing, infrastructure, maintenance, operations, and future enhancement costs.

05. Common AS/400 Migration Risks and How to Reduce Them

AS/400 migration requires more than converting application code. Organizations must also preserve the accuracy of existing business processes and processing results.

In critical systems such as order management, inventory management, and accounting, data inconsistencies or differences in processing results can affect business operations.

Potential RiskRecommended Mitigation
Missing Business LogicAnalyze existing programs and compare legacy and new system results.
Data Migration InconsistenciesPerform data mapping, record reconciliation, and critical field validation.
Integration FailuresAssess interfaces and conduct end-to-end integration testing.
Batch Processing Performance IssuesConduct performance tests using production-like data volumes.
Business Disruption During CutoverPrepare cutover rehearsals and documented recovery procedures.

When migrating RPG applications to Java, differences in language behavior, data types, numeric calculations, character encoding, and batch processing require particular attention.

Source code conversion alone does not guarantee equivalent business outcomes. Critical processes should be tested by comparing the results of the existing and new systems against defined business requirements.

06. AS/400 Modernization Process: Five Practical Steps

A successful AS/400 modernization project requires a structured plan that considers technical feasibility, business continuity, and long-term operations.

Step 1: Assess the Existing System

Analyze RPG, COBOL, and CL programs, data structures, external integrations, and business workflows to identify current challenges and dependencies.

Step 2: Define Objectives and Scope

Clarify modernization goals, such as improving maintainability, strengthening integrations, or reducing operational workload. Identify the business functions that should be prioritized.

Step 3: Compare Modernization Approaches

Evaluate retaining IBM i, incremental application modernization, hosting migration, and system rebuilding based on cost, timeline, and project risks.

Step 4: Conduct a Proof of Concept and Migration Testing

Validate technical feasibility, processing results, and performance using selected business functions and representative datasets.

Step 5: Execute Production Cutover and Operational Transition

Prepare data migration, business testing, cutover rehearsals, and rollback procedures before transitioning to the new environment through a phased or single-stage approach.

Key Consideration: AS/400 modernization is not only about adopting new technologies. Preserving business logic and data accuracy is essential for maintaining operational reliability.

07. Frequently Asked Questions About AS/400 Modernization

Q1. Can AS/400 systems continue to be used?

IBM i continues to receive platform updates and enhancements. However, support conditions vary depending on hardware, operating system version, applications, and maintenance agreements.

Organizations should assess their current environment before deciding whether to retain or modernize the system.

Q2. Is it possible to migrate AS/400 applications to Java?

Yes. However, converting RPG or COBOL source code into Java does not automatically guarantee identical business results.

Business logic, data structures, and external integrations must be analyzed. Application redesign and comprehensive testing may also be necessary.

Q3. What is the difference between AS/400 cloud migration and system rebuilding?

Cloud migration may involve moving an existing IBM i environment to a compatible cloud platform.

System rebuilding involves recreating applications using new technologies or software packages. The scope and required effort differ significantly, so the approaches should be compared based on business objectives.

Q4. How long does an AS/400 migration project take?

The timeline depends on the number of programs, data volume, business logic complexity, external integrations, and testing requirements.

An initial system assessment is necessary to define the scope and modernization approach before developing a realistic project schedule.

08. BAP’s Legacy System Migration and Modernization Services

BAP supports legacy system modernization projects, from existing system assessment and application migration to data transformation, testing, and operational transition.

Our approach considers existing business logic, data structures, and external system integrations when evaluating modernization options.

BAP has also worked on legacy system migration projects involving order management and inventory management applications.

Through business process analysis, data migration, application development, and testing, we help organizations plan system modernization while considering business continuity.

Related Case Study: Legacy System Migration for Order and Inventory Management

Planning an AS/400 or Core System Modernization Project?

From existing system assessments and modernization strategy evaluation to data migration and testing, BAP supports organizations throughout the modernization process.

Explore BAP’s System Migration Services →

Conclusion

AS/400 modernization offers several options, including retaining IBM i, gradually modernizing applications, migrating to compatible cloud environments, and rebuilding business systems.

The most appropriate approach depends on the organization’s current challenges, business requirements, budget, timeline, and acceptable level of risk.

By carefully assessing existing systems and preserving critical business logic and data accuracy, organizations can develop a more controlled modernization strategy and prepare for long-term system sustainability.